Sometimes one function comes as an equation and the other as a graph, a table or a sentence. You can't compare the forms directly, so you compare features: y-intercepts, zeros, maximums and minimums, rates of change, where each function increases, end behavior, and which is bigger. The method: find the same feature in each form, then put the two answers side by side.
The method
Find the same feature in each form, then compare
F-IF.9 gives you two functions in two different forms: an equation, a graph, a table, or a description in words. You can't compare an equation to a graph directly. You compare the features they share.
A feature is something every function has: a y-intercept, zeros, a maximum or minimum, a rate of change, where it increases, how it behaves at the ends. Each form hides these in a different place.
Pick one feature the question asks about, such as the y-intercept.
Find it for the first function, using that function's own form.
Find the same feature for the second function, using its form.
Put the two numbers side by side. Same feature, same units, same variable.
Answer the exact question: which is greater, by how much, or on which x-values.
Example
f(x) = 2x + 5 is an equation. g is the graph of a line through (0, 3) and (2, 9). Which has the greater y-intercept? Feature: y-intercept. For f, put in x = 0: f(0) = 5. For g, the graph crosses the y-axis at (0, 3), so the y-intercept is 3. Compare 5 and 3: f has the greater y-intercept.
Where to find each feature
Average rate of change on [a, b] — (f(b) − f(a)) ÷ (b − a)
Feature
Equation
Graph
Table or words
y-intercept
Put in x = 0
Where it crosses the y-axis
The x = 0 row, or the starting value
Zero
Solve f(x) = 0
Where it meets the x-axis
An x whose output is 0, or when it lands or runs out
Maximum or minimum
Vertex of a parabola; midline ± amplitude for sine
Highest or lowest point
Biggest or smallest output, if the values turn around
Rate of change on [a, b]
Compute f(a) and f(b)
Read two points
Use the two rows
Increasing
Sign of the slope, or which side of the vertex
Climbing as you read left to right
Outputs rise as x rises
End behavior
Degree and sign of the leading coefficient, or the base
Where the ends point
Only a trend; words may tell you more
Every row works for every pair of forms. Just use the right column for each function.
Example
f(x) = x². Table for g: x = 1, 3 gives g(1) = 2, g(3) = 8. Compare the average rate of change on [1, 3]. f: (f(3) − f(1)) ÷ 2 = (9 − 1) ÷ 2 = 4. g: (8 − 2) ÷ 2 = 3. f changes faster on [1, 3].
Equation vs. graph
Quadratic equation vs. quadratic graph
f is an equation, f(x) = x² − 2x − 3 (blue). g is only a graph (orange).
From the equation: f(0) = −3 is the y-intercept. Factoring, (x − 3)(x + 1) = 0, so the zeros are −1 and 3. The vertex is halfway between them at x = 1, and f(1) = −4. The parabola opens up, so −4 is a minimum.
From the graph: the y-intercept is 8, the zeros are −2 and 4, and the top point is (1, 9). It opens down, so 9 is a maximum.
Feature
f (equation)
g (graph)
y-intercept
−3
8
Zeros
−1 and 3
−2 and 4
Vertex
(1, −4), a minimum
(1, 9), a maximum
Increasing
x > 1
x < 1
Example
Which function has the greater y-intercept? Which has zeros farther apart? g's y-intercept is 8 and f's is −3, so g is greater. Distance between zeros: f has 3 − (−1) = 4, g has 4 − (−2) = 6. g's zeros are farther apart.
Trap: Both vertices sit at x = 1, but that doesn't make the functions alike. To compare maximums you compare heights. g has a maximum of 9. f opens up, so it has no maximum at all.
Line vs. absolute value
f(x) = −2x + 6 is an equation (blue). g is a graph of an absolute value V (orange).
f: the y-intercept is 6. Solving −2x + 6 = 0 gives the zero x = 3. The slope is −2, so f decreases everywhere and never has a maximum or minimum.
g: the y-intercept is −2, the zeros are −4 and 2, and the vertex (the minimum) is (−1, −3). It decreases for x < −1 and increases for x > −1.
The graphs cross where f(x) = g(x). On the right branch, g(x) = x − 2, so −2x + 6 = x − 2 gives x = 8/3. To the left of 8/3, f is greater. To the right, g is greater.
Feature
f (equation)
g (graph)
y-intercept
6
−2
Zeros
3
−4 and 2
Minimum
none
−3 at x = −1
Increasing
never
x > −1
Rate of change on [0, 3]
−2
1
Example
Find g's average rate of change on [−1, 3] from the graph. Read (−1, −3) and (3, 1). The rate is (1 − (−3)) ÷ (3 − (−1)) = 4 ÷ 4 = 1.
Trap: An average rate can hide a turn. On [−3, 1], g(−3) = −1 and g(1) = −1, so the average rate is 0. But g falls and then rises on that interval. Check the shape before you trust one number.
Sine equation vs. sine graph
From a maximum and minimum — midline = (max + min) ÷ 2, amplitude = (max − min) ÷ 2
f(x) = 2 sin x is an equation (blue). g is a graph (orange), shown from 0 to 2π.
From the equation: the maximum is 2, the minimum is −2, the midline is y = 0, the amplitude is 2, and the period is 2π.
From the graph: the highest point is 4 and the lowest is −2. It repeats twice between 0 and 2π, so the period is π.
From a graph's max and min you can build the midline and amplitude yourself.
Trap: g is taller, but its minimum is not lower. Both have a minimum of −2, so they tie. A bigger amplitude doesn't mean a lower minimum when the midline has moved.
Equation vs. table or words
Two projectiles: equation vs. table
Projectile A is an equation: h(t) = −16t² + 64t, height in feet after t seconds. Projectile B is a table.
For A: it starts at h(0) = 0. The vertex is at t = 64 ÷ 32 = 2, and h(2) = 64. It lands when h = 0: −16t(t − 4) = 0, so at t = 4.
For B: the t = 0 row says it starts at 48 ft. The heights go 48, 64, 48, so the highest value is 64, and the table is symmetric around t = 1. It lands at t = 3, where the height is 0.
t (seconds)
0
1
2
3
B height (ft)
48
64
48
0
Example
Which projectile is in the air longer, and for how much longer? A lands at t = 4 and B lands at t = 3. A is in the air 1 second longer.
Trap: Both projectiles reach a maximum of 64 ft, so they tie on height. They differ in when: A peaks at t = 2 and B peaks at t = 1. Compare the feature the question asks about, not the one that looks different.
Two savings plans: words vs. table
Plan A in words: start with $100 and add $30 every month. Its balance is 100, 130, 160, 190, 220 for months 0 to 4.
Plan B as a table (below). Each balance is 1.5 times the one before: 120 ÷ 80 = 1.5, 180 ÷ 120 = 1.5, and so on.
Rate of change on [0, 2]: A is (160 − 100) ÷ 2 = 30 per month. B is (180 − 80) ÷ 2 = 50 per month. On [2, 4]: A is still 30. B is (405 − 180) ÷ 2 = 112.5.
Month
0
1
2
3
4
Plan B balance ($)
80
120
180
270
405
Plan A balance ($)
100
130
160
190
220
Plan A's row was worked out from the words.
Example
Which plan has more money at month 2, and by how much? A: 100 + 30 · 2 = 160. B: 180 from the table. B has $20 more.
Trap: Plan A is ahead at month 0 and month 1, so it is tempting to say A is better. Keep going: from month 2 on, B is ahead and the gap grows.
Polynomial equation vs. table
p(x) = x³ − 4x is an equation. q is a cubic polynomial given by the table below.
For p: p(0) = 0. Factoring, x(x − 2)(x + 2) = 0 gives zeros at −2, 0 and 2. A cubic with a positive leading coefficient falls on the left and rises on the right.
For q: the y-intercept is the x = 0 row, which is 0. The zeros are the x-values with output 0: −1, 0 and 1. The outputs keep dropping as x grows, and q is a cubic, so q rises on the left and falls on the right.
x
−3
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
q(x)
24
6
0
0
0
−6
−24
Example
Which function has the zero farthest from the origin? p's zeros are −2, 0, 2, and q's are −1, 0, 1. The farthest is 2 units away for p and 1 unit for q, so p.
Trap: A table can't prove end behavior, because it only lists a few x-values. Here it's safe to say q falls on the right because the words tell you q is a cubic and the outputs are heading down.
Which is bigger, and where?
Quadratic vs. exponential for x ≥ 0
From x = 4 on — 2ˣ ≥ x² for x ≥ 4
f(x) = x² is an equation (blue). g is the exponential 2ˣ, given as the table below (orange). Look at x ≥ 0.
To answer "which is bigger," compare row by row. They tie at x = 2 and x = 4. f is bigger only between them, at x = 3. g is bigger before x = 2 and after x = 4.
End behavior: f adds a bit more each step, but g doubles each step. An exponential with a base greater than 1 eventually passes any quadratic, and it stays ahead.
x
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
f(x) = x²
0
1
4
9
16
25
36
g(x) = 2ˣ
1
2
4
8
16
32
64
Example
How much bigger is g than f at x = 6? 64 − 36 = 28. g is greater by 28.
Trap: Don't stop at the first x-value you check. At x = 3, f is bigger. If you only looked there you'd say the quadratic wins, and you'd miss that the exponential takes over after x = 4.
Memory hook: Same feature, same units, then compare. Check more than one x before you say who's bigger.
NC Math 3 · NC.M3.F-IF.9
Comparing Functions in Different Forms
Practice
Name ____________________ Date ____________
1. f(x) = 2x + 3 is given by an equation. The graph shows g. (a) Which function has the greater y-intercept? (b) Which has the greater zero? (c) Which function is increasing?
2. f(x) = −x² + 6x − 5 is an equation. g is a quadratic given by the table. Which has the greater maximum? At what x does each reach its maximum?
x
0
1
2
3
4
g(x)
3
6
7
6
3
3. p(x) = x³ − x² − 6x is given by an equation. g is the graph of a cubic. Find the zeros of each. Which function has the smallest zero, and which has the largest?
4. Plan A in words: start with $50 and add $20 each month. Plan B is given by the table. Which plan's balance grows faster on average from month 0 to month 3? Give each plan's average rate.
Month
0
1
2
3
Plan B ($)
30
60
120
240
5. f(x) = 3 · 2ˣ is an equation. g is described in words: "g is a quadratic function whose graph opens downward." Describe the end behavior of each. For large x, which is greater?
6. f(x) = 10x is an equation. g is the exponential given by the table. At which of the table's x-values is g greater than f? Which grows more as x gets large?
x
0
1
2
3
4
5
g(x)
3
6
12
24
48
96
7. f(x) = 2 sin(2x) + 3 is an equation. The graph shows g. Which function has the greater amplitude? Which has the greater minimum? How many full cycles does each complete on [0, 2π]?
8. g is the graph shown. f is described in words: "f is a linear function whose graph passes through (0, 6) and (3, 0)." Compare their y-intercepts and zeros. On which x-values is f greater than g?
NC Math 3 · NC.M3.F-IF.9
Comparing Functions in Different Forms
Practice answer key
Name ____________________ Date ____________
1. (a) g, since 5 > 3. (b) g, whose zero is 5, versus f's zero of −3/2. (c) f is increasing and g is decreasing.
Feature by feature. (a) f(0) = 3. The graph of g crosses the y-axis at (0, 5). 5 is greater than 3, so g. (b) Solve 2x + 3 = 0 to get x = −3/2. The graph of g meets the x-axis at x = 5. 5 is greater than −3/2, so g. (c) f has slope 2, which is positive, so it increases. g goes down as you read left to right, so it is decreasing.
2. g has the greater maximum: 7 at x = 2. f's maximum is 4 at x = 3.
For f, the vertex is at x = −6 ÷ (2 · −1) = 3, and f(3) = −9 + 18 − 5 = 4. For g, the outputs go 3, 6, 7, 6, 3, rising and then falling in a symmetric way, so the top is 7 at x = 2. Compare the maximums, 7 and 4: g is greater. Note that the x-values differ, which is a different feature from the heights.
3. p has zeros −2, 0 and 3. g has zeros −3, 1 and 2. g has the smallest zero (−3) and p has the largest zero (3).
Factor p: x(x² − x − 6) = x(x − 3)(x + 2), so the zeros are −2, 0 and 3. Read g from where its graph meets the x-axis: −3, 1 and 2. The smallest zero is −3, which belongs to g, and the largest is 3, which belongs to p. Each function has a smallest and a largest zero, so check both.
4. Plan B: $70 per month, versus $20 per month for Plan A.
Month
0
1
2
3
Plan A ($)
50
70
90
110
Plan B ($)
30
60
120
240
Plan A adds the same $20 every month, so its average rate on any interval is $20 per month. For B, use the table: (240 − 30) ÷ (3 − 0) = 210 ÷ 3 = 70 dollars per month. 70 is greater than 20, so B grows faster. B ends with more money too: $240 versus A's $50 + 20 · 3 = $110.
5. f: as x → ∞, f → ∞; as x → −∞, f approaches 0. g: both ends go to −∞. For large x, f is greater.
Exponential with base 2 > 1: f grows without bound as x gets large, and as x gets very negative it shrinks toward 0 but never reaches it (3 · 2ˣ is always positive). A quadratic that opens down falls at both ends. For large x, f is large and positive and g is large and negative, so f is greater.
6. g is greater at x = 0, 4 and 5. f is greater at x = 1, 2 and 3. g wins for large x.
x
0
1
2
3
4
5
f(x) = 10x
0
10
20
30
40
50
g(x)
3
6
12
24
48
96
Compare row by row. x = 0: g is 3 and f is 0, g greater. x = 1: 6 and 10, f. x = 2: 12 and 20, f. x = 3: 24 and 30, f. x = 4: 48 and 40, g. x = 5: 96 and 50, g. f adds 10 each step. g doubles each step, so it passes f and keeps pulling away. That is why g is greater for large x.
7. g has the greater amplitude (3 versus 2). f has the greater minimum (1 versus −2). f completes 2 cycles and g completes 1.
From the equation f: amplitude 2, midline y = 3, so the max is 3 + 2 = 5 and the min is 3 − 2 = 1. Period: 2π ÷ 2 = π, so 2 cycles on [0, 2π]. From the graph g: the max is 4 and the min is −2, so the amplitude is (4 − (−2)) ÷ 2 = 3 and the midline is 1. It makes one full wave on [0, 2π]. Compare: amplitude 3 > 2 (g), minimum 1 > −2 (f).
8. y-intercepts: f has 6 and g has 3, so f is greater. Zeros: f has 3, g has −3 and 5. f is greater than g for x < 1 and g is greater for x > 1. They are equal at (1, 4).
f: the slope is (0 − 6) ÷ (3 − 0) = −2, so f(x) = −2x + 6. Its y-intercept is 6 and its zero is 3. g from the graph: y-intercept 3, zeros −3 and 5, vertex (1, 4). For where f > g, set them equal. Left of the vertex g(x) = x + 3, so −2x + 6 = x + 3 gives x = 1. That is the vertex, (1, 4), and f(1) = 4 too. At x = 0, f = 6 and g = 3, so f is greater to the left. At x = 2, f = 2 and g = 3, so g is greater to the right.
NC Math 3 · NC.M3.F-IF.9
Comparing Functions in Different Forms
Quiz
Name ____________________ Date ____________
1. f(x) = 2(x − 4)² − 5 is given by an equation. The graph shows g, a parabola. (a) Which function has the greater y-intercept? (b) Which function has a minimum value and which has a maximum value? Give each value. (c) Which function has the greater average rate of change on [0, 1]?
2. f(x) = 5x² is given by an equation. g is described in words: g starts at 1 when x = 0 and triples each time x goes up by 1. Compare f and g at x = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. At which of these x-values is g greater? Which function is greater for large x?
3. f(x) = −x²(x − 4) is given by an equation. The graph shows g, a polynomial. (a) Which function has more distinct x-intercepts? (b) Describe the end behavior of each function. (c) Which function has the greatest zero? At which zero of each function does the graph touch the x-axis instead of crossing it?
4. Channel A is described in words: it has 65 followers now and gains 30 followers every week. Channel B is given by the table, where t is the number of weeks from now. (a) Find each channel's average rate of change on [0, 2] and on [2, 4]. (b) Which channel has more followers at week 4? (c) Which channel will eventually have more followers, and why?
Week t
0
1
2
3
4
Channel B
10
20
40
80
160
5. Tide A is given by the equation h(t) = 6 sin(πt/6) + 8, with h in feet and t in hours. Tide B is given by the table, which shows one full cycle of a sine-shaped wave. (a) Which tide has the greater maximum? (b) Which has the greater minimum? (c) Which has the longer period? Give each period.
t (hours)
0
2
4
6
8
B height (ft)
6
10
6
2
6
6. f(x) = x² − 6x + 5 is given by an equation. The graph shows g, a line. (a) Which function has the greater y-intercept? (b) At which x-values do f and g have the same output? (c) For which x-values is f(x) greater than g(x)?
NC Math 3 · NC.M3.F-IF.9
Comparing Functions in Different Forms
Quiz answer key
Name ____________________ Date ____________
1. (a) f, since 27 > 6. (b) f has a minimum of −5 (at x = 4) and no maximum. g has a maximum of 8 (at x = −1) and no minimum. (c) g: its average rate is −6, versus −14 for f.
(a) f(0) = 2(−4)² − 5 = 27. The graph of g crosses the y-axis at (0, 6). 27 > 6, so f. (b) f has a positive leading coefficient, so it opens up and its lowest point is the vertex (4, −5). It has no maximum. The graph of g opens down, so its vertex (−1, 8) is a maximum and it has no minimum. A minimum and a maximum are different features, so there is no greater minimum to pick here. (c) f(1) = 2(−3)² − 5 = 13, so f's rate is (13 − 27) ÷ 1 = −14. On the graph g(0) = 6 and g(1) = 0, so g's rate is (0 − 6) ÷ 1 = −6. Since −6 is greater than −14, g has the greater rate. Both functions fall on [0, 1], but f falls faster.
2. g is greater at x = 0, 4 and 5. f is greater at x = 1, 2 and 3. For large x, g is greater.
x
0
1
2
3
4
5
f(x) = 5x²
0
5
20
45
80
125
g(x) = 3x
1
3
9
27
81
243
Tripling each step from a start of 1 gives g(x) = 3x. Compare row by row. x = 0: g is 1 and f is 0, so g. x = 1: 3 and 5, so f. x = 2: 9 and 20, so f. x = 3: 27 and 45, so f. x = 4: 81 and 80, so g, but only just. x = 5: 243 and 125, so g. f adds a bit more each step, but g multiplies by 3 each step. An exponential with a base greater than 1 eventually passes any quadratic and stays ahead, so g is greater for large x.
3. (a) g has 3 (x = −2, 1, 3). f has 2 (x = 0 and 4). (b) f rises on the left and falls on the right. g rises on both ends. (c) f has the greatest zero (4 versus 3). f touches at 0 and g touches at 1.
From the equation, −x²(x − 4) = 0 gives x = 0 (a double zero, from x²) and x = 4, so f has 2 distinct zeros. Reading g, the graph meets the axis at −2, 1 and 3, so it has 3. The factor x² means f touches the axis at 0 and turns around. On g the graph touches the axis at 1 and turns around, while it crosses at −2 and 3. For f, the leading term is −x³, which is a degree 3 term with a negative sign: as x → −∞ it goes to +∞, and as x → +∞ it goes to −∞. The graph of g opens up on both ends, an even degree with a positive leading coefficient. The greatest zero is 4 for f and 3 for g, so f.
4. (a) A: 30 followers per week on both intervals. B: 15 per week on [0, 2] and 60 per week on [2, 4]. (b) A, with 185 versus 160. (c) B: its followers double every week, so it passes A (at week 5, B has 320 and A has 215).
Week t
0
1
2
3
4
5
Channel A
65
95
125
155
185
215
Channel B
10
20
40
80
160
320
A adds the same 30 each week, so its average rate is 30 on any interval. For B, on [0, 2] the rate is (40 − 10) ÷ 2 = 15, and on [2, 4] it is (160 − 40) ÷ 2 = 60. At week 4, A has 65 + 30 · 4 = 185 and B has 160, so A is still ahead even though B is growing faster there. B doubles each week (20 ÷ 10 = 2, 40 ÷ 20 = 2, and so on), so it is exponential, while A is linear. An exponential with a base greater than 1 eventually passes any line. At week 5, A has 215 and B has 320, so B has taken the lead.
5. (a) Tide A: its maximum is 14 ft, versus 10 ft. (b) They tie: both minimums are 2 ft. (c) Tide A: its period is 12 hours, versus 8 hours.
For A, the amplitude is 6 and the midline is y = 8, so the maximum is 8 + 6 = 14 and the minimum is 8 − 6 = 2. The period is 2π ÷ (π/6) = 12 hours. For B, the table rises to 10, falls to 2 and is back at 6 by t = 8, so the maximum is 10, the minimum is 2, and one cycle takes 8 hours. Its midline is (10 + 2) ÷ 2 = 6 and its amplitude is 4. Compare: 14 > 10 for the maximum, and 2 = 2 for the minimum. A has the greater amplitude, but its midline is higher, so its minimum is no lower than B's. A bigger amplitude does not always mean a lower minimum. The periods are 12 and 8, so A is longer.
6. (a) f, since 5 > −7. (b) x = 2 and x = 6. (c) x < 2 or x > 6.
(a) f(0) = 5. The line g crosses the y-axis at (0, −7). 5 > −7, so f. (b) Read g from the graph: it passes through (0, −7) and (4, 1), so its slope is (1 − (−7)) ÷ 4 = 2 and g(x) = 2x − 7. Set f(x) = g(x): x² − 6x + 5 = 2x − 7, so x² − 8x + 12 = 0 and (x − 2)(x − 6) = 0. Check: f(2) = −3 = g(2) and f(6) = 5 = g(6). (c) f(x) − g(x) = (x − 2)(x − 6) is an upward parabola, which is positive outside its zeros. So f is greater for x < 2 and for x > 6, and g is greater between 2 and 6. Check x = 4: f = −3 and g = 1, so g is greater there. Check x = 7: f = 12 and g = 7, so f is greater. Looking at only a few x-values near the middle would miss the second region.