NC.M3.A-REI.1 · A-REI.2Print or save as PDF
Solving Equations and Extraneous Solutions
How to justify each step when you solve an equation, which steps can add or lose solutions, and how to solve rational equations (including ones from work-rate and speed problems) without being fooled by extraneous solutions.
Source: Authored for NCMath (not from the PDF prototype) — needs teacher review
Every step needs a reason
Solving is a chain of reasons
Solving an equation is not a list of moves to memorize. Each line must follow from the line before it, and you should be able to say why.
The reason is usually a property of equality (do the same thing to both sides), the distributive property, or combining like terms. If you can name the reason, you can defend the method.
A good justification also says what is allowed. For example, you may multiply both sides by a number only if that number is not 0.
| Reason | What it says |
|---|---|
| Distributive property | a(b + c) = ab + ac |
| Combine like terms | Add or subtract terms with the same variable part |
| Addition / subtraction property of equality | Add or subtract the same number on both sides. The equation stays true. |
| Multiplication / division property of equality | Multiply or divide both sides by the same nonzero number. The equation stays true. |
| Factoring and zero-product property | If a · b = 0, then a = 0 or b = 0 |
Worked example with a reason for each step
| Step | Reason |
|---|---|
| 3(x − 2) + 5 = 2x + 7 | Given |
| 3x − 6 + 5 = 2x + 7 | Distributive property |
| 3x − 1 = 2x + 7 | Combine like terms |
| x − 1 = 7 | Subtraction property of equality (subtract 2x from both sides) |
| x = 8 | Addition property of equality (add 1 to both sides) |
Example
Solve 3(x − 2) + 5 = 2x + 7 and give a reason for every step.
The table below gives each step and its reason. The solution is x = 8. Check in the original: 3(8 − 2) + 5 = 23 and 2(8) + 7 = 23.
The table below gives each step and its reason. The solution is x = 8. Check in the original: 3(8 − 2) + 5 = 23 and 2(8) + 7 = 23.
Trap: Writing "move the 2x over" is not a reason. What you really did was subtract 2x from both sides. Say that.
Steps that can add or lose solutions
Some moves are not reversible
Adding, subtracting, and multiplying or dividing by a nonzero number are reversible. The new equation has exactly the same solutions as the old one.
Some moves are not reversible. They can add solutions that do not work (extraneous solutions) or lose solutions that do. Whenever you use one, you must check.
Why squaring adds a solution: from a = b you can get a² = b², but a² = b² also happens when a = −b. The new equation accepts both.
| Move | What can go wrong | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Multiply both sides by an expression with x in it | The expression can equal 0. Then you have multiplied by 0, and a false equation can look true. This can ADD a solution. | Multiplying by (x − 2) adds x = 2 as a candidate |
| Square both sides | Two different values can have the same square. This can ADD a solution. | √(x + 6) = x becomes x + 6 = x², which also accepts x = −2 |
| Divide both sides by an expression with x in it | The expression can equal 0, and you cannot divide by 0. This can LOSE a solution. | Dividing x² = 5x by x loses x = 0 |
Trap: Never divide both sides by a variable expression. Move everything to one side and factor instead: x² − 5x = 0 gives x(x − 5) = 0, so x = 0 or x = 5.
Worked example: one solution lost, one added
Example
Solve x² = 5x two ways. Then solve √(x + 6) = x.
Dividing x² = 5x by x gives x = 5 and loses x = 0. Factoring x(x − 5) = 0 gives both, x = 0 and x = 5. For √(x + 6) = x, squaring gives x + 6 = x², so x² − x − 6 = 0, so (x − 3)(x + 2) = 0. The candidates are 3 and −2. Check: √9 = 3 works. For x = −2, √4 = 2, which is not −2, so −2 is extraneous. The only solution is x = 3.
Dividing x² = 5x by x gives x = 5 and loses x = 0. Factoring x(x − 5) = 0 gives both, x = 0 and x = 5. For √(x + 6) = x, squaring gives x + 6 = x², so x² − x − 6 = 0, so (x − 3)(x + 2) = 0. The candidates are 3 and −2. Check: √9 = 3 works. For x = −2, √4 = 2, which is not −2, so −2 is extraneous. The only solution is x = 3.
Rational equations and extraneous solutions
Clear the denominators, then check against the original
A rational equation has a variable in a denominator. The usual method is to multiply both sides by the common denominator so the fractions disappear.
That step multiplies by an expression with x in it. If a candidate makes that expression 0, the cleared equation can be true even though the original is undefined. That candidate is an extraneous solution.
In the graph, the blue curve is the left side and the orange curve is the right side. They cross only at x = 1. At x = 2 both curves shoot off along the dashed line, so there is no point there for them to share.
- Before you solve, list the values that make any denominator 0. These are excluded.
- Multiply every term on both sides by the common denominator. Cancel.
- Solve the equation that is left. These are your candidates.
- Test every candidate in the ORIGINAL equation, not the cleared one. Throw out any candidate that is excluded or does not work.
Blue: x²/(x − 2). Orange: 4/(x − 2) + 3. They cross at (1, −1) only.
Example
Solve x²/(x − 2) = 4/(x − 2) + 3.
Excluded value: x = 2. Multiply every term by (x − 2): x² = 4 + 3(x − 2). Then x² − 3x + 2 = 0, so (x − 1)(x − 2) = 0, giving candidates x = 1 and x = 2. Check x = 1: left 1/(−1) = −1, right 4/(−1) + 3 = −1. It works. Check x = 2: both denominators are 0, so the original is undefined. x = 2 is extraneous. The only solution is x = 1.
Excluded value: x = 2. Multiply every term by (x − 2): x² = 4 + 3(x − 2). Then x² − 3x + 2 = 0, so (x − 1)(x − 2) = 0, giving candidates x = 1 and x = 2. Check x = 1: left 1/(−1) = −1, right 4/(−1) + 3 = −1. It works. Check x = 2: both denominators are 0, so the original is undefined. x = 2 is extraneous. The only solution is x = 1.
Trap: Checking a candidate in the cleared equation proves nothing. x = 2 makes x² = 4 + 3(x − 2) true (4 = 4). Only the original equation can reject it.
Sometimes every candidate works
Clearing denominators makes extraneous solutions possible, not certain. If no candidate makes a denominator 0, there is nothing to throw out. You must still check, because that is the only way to know.
Example
Solve 1/x + 1/(x + 2) = 3/4.
Excluded values: x = 0 and x = −2. Multiply every term by 4x(x + 2): 4(x + 2) + 4x = 3x(x + 2). So 8x + 8 = 3x² + 6x, and 3x² − 2x − 8 = 0, which factors as (3x + 4)(x − 2) = 0. The candidates are x = 2 and x = −4/3. Neither is 0 or −2, so neither makes a denominator 0. Check x = 2: 1/2 + 1/4 = 3/4. Check x = −4/3: −3/4 + 3/2 = 3/4. Both work.
Excluded values: x = 0 and x = −2. Multiply every term by 4x(x + 2): 4(x + 2) + 4x = 3x(x + 2). So 8x + 8 = 3x² + 6x, and 3x² − 2x − 8 = 0, which factors as (3x + 4)(x − 2) = 0. The candidates are x = 2 and x = −4/3. Neither is 0 or −2, so neither makes a denominator 0. Check x = 2: 1/2 + 1/4 = 3/4. Check x = −4/3: −3/4 + 3/2 = 3/4. Both work.
Sometimes no candidate works
If every candidate is extraneous, the original equation has no solution. That is a real answer, not a mistake.
Example
Solve x/(x − 3) = 3/(x − 3) + 2.
Excluded value: x = 3. Multiply every term by (x − 3): x = 3 + 2(x − 3), so x = 2x − 3, so x = 3. The only candidate is the excluded value. At x = 3 both fractions have denominator 0, so it fails. The equation has no solution.
Excluded value: x = 3. Multiply every term by (x − 3): x = 3 + 2(x − 3), so x = 2x − 3, so x = 3. The only candidate is the excluded value. At x = 3 both fractions have denominator 0, so it fails. The equation has no solution.
Rational equations from context
Work rates
If a job takes t hours alone, the worker finishes 1/t of the job each hour. Rates add when people work together.
So the model is: (1/time for A) + (1/time for B) = 1/(time together).
Example
Pump A fills a tank alone in t hours. Pump B alone takes 3 hours longer. Together they fill it in 2 hours. Find t.
Model: 1/t + 1/(t + 3) = 1/2. Multiply by 2t(t + 3): 2(t + 3) + 2t = t(t + 3). So 4t + 6 = t² + 3t, and t² − t − 6 = 0, so (t − 3)(t + 2) = 0. The candidates are t = 3 and t = −2. Neither makes a denominator 0, but a time cannot be negative, so the context rejects t = −2. Pump A takes 3 hours and pump B takes 6 hours. Check: 1/3 + 1/6 = 1/2.
Model: 1/t + 1/(t + 3) = 1/2. Multiply by 2t(t + 3): 2(t + 3) + 2t = t(t + 3). So 4t + 6 = t² + 3t, and t² − t − 6 = 0, so (t − 3)(t + 2) = 0. The candidates are t = 3 and t = −2. Neither makes a denominator 0, but a time cannot be negative, so the context rejects t = −2. Pump A takes 3 hours and pump B takes 6 hours. Check: 1/3 + 1/6 = 1/2.
Trap: Do not call t = −2 "extraneous" for the same reason as before. It does not break the original equation. The context makes it impossible. Always ask: does this answer make sense for the situation?
Distance, rate and time
Time = distance ÷ rate. A trip with two parts gives an equation with a variable in the denominator.
Average speed is total distance ÷ total time. It is not the average of the two speeds.
Example
A bus travels 60 miles at r mph, then returns the same 60 miles at (r + 10) mph. The total driving time is 5 hours. Find r.
Model: 60/r + 60/(r + 10) = 5. Multiply by r(r + 10): 60(r + 10) + 60r = 5r(r + 10). So 120r + 600 = 5r² + 50r, and r² − 14r − 120 = 0, so (r − 20)(r + 6) = 0. Candidates: r = 20 and r = −6. A speed cannot be negative, so r = 20. The bus goes 20 mph out and 30 mph back. Check: 60/20 + 60/30 = 3 + 2 = 5 hours. Its average speed is 120 ÷ 5 = 24 mph, not 25.
Model: 60/r + 60/(r + 10) = 5. Multiply by r(r + 10): 60(r + 10) + 60r = 5r(r + 10). So 120r + 600 = 5r² + 50r, and r² − 14r − 120 = 0, so (r − 20)(r + 6) = 0. Candidates: r = 20 and r = −6. A speed cannot be negative, so r = 20. The bus goes 20 mph out and 30 mph back. Check: 60/20 + 60/30 = 3 + 2 = 5 hours. Its average speed is 120 ÷ 5 = 24 mph, not 25.
Memory hook: Reason for every step. Multiply by something with x, square, or divide by x: check. Always test in the ORIGINAL equation.
Practice
1. Solve 4(x + 1) − 2 = 2x + 10. The table gives each step; in your head, name the reason for each.
| Step | Reason |
|---|---|
| 4(x + 1) − 2 = 2x + 10 | Given |
| 4x + 4 − 2 = 2x + 10 | ? |
| 4x + 2 = 2x + 10 | ? |
| 2x + 2 = 10 | ? |
| 2x = 8 | ? |
| x = 4 | ? |
2. A student solves x² = 5x by dividing both sides by x and gets x = 5. What solution did the student lose, and which step lost it? Find all solutions correctly.
3. Solve √(x + 6) = x. Say which step creates a candidate that fails, and why it fails.
4. Solve 1/x + 1/(x + 2) = 3/4. Do both candidates work?
5. Solve 1/(x − 3) + 1/(x + 3) = 6/(x² − 9). Explain why your candidate fails.
6. Solve 3/(x − 2) + 1 = 6/(x(x − 2)). Find every candidate and say which are extraneous.
7. Pipe A fills a pool alone in t hours. Pipe B alone takes 5 hours longer. Together they fill it in 6 hours. Write an equation and find how long each pipe takes alone. Explain why one candidate is rejected.
8. A train travels 90 miles at r mph and returns the same 90 miles at (r + 15) mph. The total travel time is 5 hours. Find r and the train's average speed for the round trip.